Understanding Your Insurance Score: What It Is and Why It Matters

What is an Insurance Score?

An insurance credit score is a numerical value derived from specific elements of your credit history that some insurance companies use to help predict the likelihood of you filing a claim. The score helps insurers assess risk when determining what to charge you for auto or home insurance. Unlike a credit score, which measures your creditworthiness for lenders, an insurance score focuses on your financial behaviors that correlate with insurance risk.

Insurance scores are calculated using factors like your payment history, the length of your credit history, outstanding balances, and more. They are loosely based on your credit score, but it would be incorrect to say it was the same as your FICO score. By analyzing these behaviors, insurers can better estimate how likely you are to file a claim in the future. A high insurance score indicates that you’re less likely to make a claim, while a lower score suggests higher risk, which could lead to higher insurance premiums.

Difference Between an Insurance Score and a Credit Score

Although an insurance score is derived from elements of your credit report, it is not the same as a credit score (FICO). Here are some key differences:

• Credit Score: This score is used by lenders, like mortgage or credit card companies, to assess your creditworthiness. It determines whether you qualify for loans, the interest rate you receive, and your ability to repay borrowed money.
• Insurance Score: Insurance companies use this score to predict how likely you are to file an insurance claim. They do not assess your ability to repay debt but rather focus on behaviors that correlate with risk, such as timely bill payments and managing credit balances. Insurers typically do not look at your exact credit score; instead, they use only certain financial indicators that have been shown to predict insurance claims.

One key factor in calculating an insurance score is credit history length, which refers to how long an individual has maintained a line of credit and accounts for 15% of the score.

While both scores pull information from your credit report, their purposes and outcomes are different. Your insurance score won’t affect your ability to get a loan, but it can influence how much you pay for insurance.

Why Insurance Companies Use Insurance Scores

Insurance companies began using credit-based insurance scores in the 1980s, recognizing a correlation between certain financial behaviors and the likelihood of filing a claim. Although the exact reason for this correlation isn’t definitively known, insurers have found that people with higher insurance scores tend to file fewer claims. FICO, a data and analytics company, measures credit risks by quantifying various factors, which helps insurance companies set premiums that reflect the level of risk you present as a policyholder.

By incorporating insurance scores, companies can refine their pricing models, ensuring that lower-risk customers benefit from lower premiums. This method allows insurers to offer coverage to a broader group of people, including those who may have been considered too risky based on other factors like driving history alone​.

Brief Overview of How It Impacts Your Premiums

Your insurance score plays a significant role in determining your insurance premiums. If your score is high, it suggests that you are less likely to file a claim, making you a lower risk to the insurer. As a result, you may qualify for lower premiums. On the other hand, if your score is lower, insurers may view you as a higher risk, potentially leading to higher premiums. Insurance scores range from 200 to 997, with scores above 775 deemed as good.

While your insurance score isn’t the only factor that determines your premium, it is a key component. Other factors, such as your driving record, the type of coverage you select, and where you live, also contribute to your overall rate. However, because the insurance score is based on your credit behavior, improving your financial habits can positively impact both your credit and insurance scores over time, leading to lower insurance costs​​.

How Your Insurance Score Is Calculated

Your insurance score is determined by several factors from your credit history, which are indicators of financial behavior and risk. Insurers use these elements to predict the likelihood of you filing an insurance claim. Below are the key factors involved:

• Payment History: Insurers look at whether you’ve consistently paid your bills on time. Late or missed payments suggest financial instability, which could indicate higher risk and lower your insurance score.
• Length of Credit History: A longer credit history gives insurers more information about your financial habits. A lengthy and well-managed credit history is seen as more favorable, leading to a higher score.
• Credit Account Balances: The amount of debt you carry compared to your available credit, known as your credit utilization ratio, affects your score. Lower balances are better, while high balances signal financial stress, which could lower your insurance score.
• Number of Credit Accounts: The total number of credit accounts, including loans and credit cards, also plays a role. Having a mix of accounts and managing them responsibly improves your score, while too many accounts can indicate overextension.
• Credit Inquiries: Hard inquiries from applying for credit can slightly lower your score, especially if there are many inquiries in a short period. However, “soft inquiries,” like checking your own credit, do not impact your score.
• Bankruptcies, Foreclosures, and Other Negative Activities: Major financial events like bankruptcies and foreclosures significantly lower your score. These indicate a high level of financial distress and are viewed as a strong predictor of future claims.

How These Factors Influence Your Score Differently Across States

State laws can affect how much weight is given to certain factors. For example, some states restrict the use of bankruptcies or credit inquiries in calculating insurance scores, which may lessen their impact in those regions. This means that how much these factors influence your score can vary depending on where you live​​. State regulations can also impact auto insurance premiums based on credit-based insurance scores, as some states allow this practice while others restrict it.

Credit-Based Insurance Scores

Understanding the Role of Credit in Insurance Scoring

Credit-based insurance scores are a crucial factor in determining your insurance premiums. These scores are derived from your credit history and are used by insurance companies to predict the likelihood of you filing a claim. Essentially, a credit-based insurance score is a three-digit number that reflects your creditworthiness and helps insurers assess your risk level.

Insurance companies calculate these scores using various elements of your credit history, including your payment history, outstanding debt, the length of your credit history, pursuit of new credit, and the mix of credit accounts you have. For instance, consistently paying your bills on time and maintaining low balances on your credit cards can positively impact your score, while late payments and high debt levels can lower it.

Policyholders with higher credit-based insurance scores are considered lower-risk and may qualify for lower premiums. Conversely, those with lower scores are viewed as higher-risk and may face higher premiums. It’s important to note that while credit scores and credit-based insurance scores are related, they serve different purposes. Credit scores are used to determine your creditworthiness for loans and credit cards, whereas credit-based insurance scores are specifically used to predict the likelihood of insurance claims.

Understanding how your credit behaviors influence your insurance score can help you take steps to improve it, potentially leading to lower insurance costs.

Insurance Score vs. Credit Score

While both an insurance score and a credit score use information from your credit report, they serve different purposes and are used by different entities. Here’s a breakdown of the key differences:

Key Differences Between an Insurance Score and a Credit Score

• Purpose:
  • Credit Score: Used by lenders to assess your creditworthiness and ability to repay loans or credit card debt.
  • Insurance Score: Used by insurers to predict the likelihood of you filing an insurance claim. It doesn’t evaluate your creditworthiness but focuses on financial behaviors linked to insurance risk.
• Factors Considered:
  • Both scores use data like payment history and credit balances, but insurance scores weigh these factors differently. For example, insurance scores emphasize your payment consistency and how much of your available credit you’re using.
• Visibility:
  • Credit Score: Visible to lenders, landlords, and others when you apply for credit or housing.
  • Insurance Score: Only used by insurance companies to set premiums for auto, home, or renters insurance.
• Impact on Costs:
  • Credit Score: Affects interest rates and loan approvals.
  • Insurance Score: Directly impacts your insurance premiums, with higher scores leading to lower premiums.

---

How Lenders Use Your Credit Score vs. How Insurers Use Your Insurance Score

Lenders and Your Credit Score: Lenders use your credit score to determine your ability to repay loans. Factors like payment history, amounts owed, and length of credit history help lenders assess the risk of lending you money. A higher credit score typically results in lower interest rates and better loan terms, while a lower score can lead to higher costs or loan denials. Auto loans are considered when determining an individual’s credit mix, which influences both credit and insurance scores.

Insurers and Your Insurance Score: Insurers use your insurance score to predict the likelihood of you filing a claim. A lower score indicates lower risk, resulting in lower insurance premiums. Insurers focus on factors like on-time payments and low credit balances, which have been shown to correlate with fewer claims. They do not use your full credit history but select specific financial behaviors that reflect insurance risk.

Why Insurers Use Insurance Scores

Insurance companies use insurance scores because they have found a strong statistical relationship between certain credit behaviors and the likelihood of filing an insurance claim. Research shows that individuals with lower insurance scores tend to file fewer claims, while those with higher scores are more likely to do so.

By using insurance scores, insurers can better predict potential insurance losses. This helps them assess the risk each customer presents and set premiums accordingly. For example, a person with a low insurance score, reflecting responsible financial behavior, is seen as a lower risk and may qualify for lower premiums. Conversely, a higher score suggests higher risk, leading to higher insurance rates.

In essence, insurance scores allow insurers to offer more tailored pricing, rewarding low-risk customers with better rates, while ensuring that premiums reflect the level of risk for all policyholders​​.

How Insurance Scores Affect Your Premiums

Your insurance score has a direct impact on the premiums you pay for policies like auto, home, or renters insurance. Insurers use your score as one of several factors to assess the risk you present and to determine how much you should be charged for coverage.

Impact of a High Insurance Score

If you have a low insurance score, it indicates to insurers that you are less likely to file claims, making you a lower-risk customer. As a result, you may qualify for lower premiums. Insurance companies reward responsible financial behavior, such as paying bills on time, maintaining low balances, and having a long, stable credit history. These actions suggest financial stability, which correlates with fewer claims, allowing insurers to offer you more competitive rates.

What Happens if You Have a Low Insurance Score?

On the other hand, a high insurance score signals to insurers that you might be a higher-risk customer, meaning you are statistically more likely to file claims. Insurers may charge higher premiums to offset this perceived risk. Factors that can lead to a high score include missed or late payments, high credit card balances, bankruptcies, or a short credit history. While a high score doesn’t prevent you from getting insurance, it often means you’ll pay more for coverage.

Why Your Score Can Fluctuate Over Time

Your insurance score can fluctuate depending on changes in your financial behaviors. For instance, paying down debt, avoiding late payments, and keeping credit balances low can improve your score over time, potentially leading to lower premiums in the future. Conversely, accumulating more debt, missing payments, or experiencing negative financial events like bankruptcy can increase your score. Regularly monitoring and improving your financial habits can help ensure that your insurance score reflects a lower risk profile, ultimately saving you money on insurance costs​​.

Can I See My Insurance Score?

Accessing Your Insurance Score and Understanding Its Implications

Unlike credit scores, insurance scores are not typically disclosed to policyholders. However, you can inquire with your insurance company to find out if they use credit-based insurance scores to determine your premiums. If they do, you can request information about your specific score.

While you may not have direct access to your insurance score, you can review your credit report, which is used to calculate it. You are entitled to a free credit report once a year from each of the three major credit reporting companies—Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion—through annualcreditreport.com. By reviewing your credit report, you can gain insights into how your credit history might be affecting your insurance score.

It’s important to remember that your insurance score is just one of many factors that insurers consider when determining your premiums. Other elements, such as your driving history, claims history, and the coverage limits you choose, also play significant roles. Regularly monitoring your credit report and understanding the factors that influence your insurance score can help you manage your premiums more effectively.

How Does Applying for Insurance Affect My Credit Score?

Exploring the Relationship Between Insurance Applications and Credit Scores

When you apply for insurance, the impact on your credit score is generally minimal. Insurance companies typically perform a soft inquiry on your credit report during the quote process. Unlike hard inquiries, which occur when you apply for credit and can affect your credit score, soft inquiries do not impact your credit score.

However, if you apply for multiple insurance policies within a short period, it could result in several soft inquiries. While these do not directly lower your credit score, they can be noted on your credit report.

It’s crucial to understand that insurance companies do not use your credit score to determine your premiums. Instead, they use credit-based insurance scores, which are calculated using your credit history to predict the likelihood of insurance claims. These scores focus on different aspects of your financial behavior than credit scores, which are used to assess your creditworthiness.

If you’re concerned about the potential impact of insurance applications on your credit score, it’s a good idea to ask your insurance company about their credit inquiry policies. Some insurers may offer alternative methods for determining premiums that do not involve credit inquiries, providing you with more options to manage your financial profile effectively.

Improving Your Insurance Score

Improving your insurance score can lead to lower premiums and better insurance options. Since your insurance score is based on certain elements of your credit history, taking steps to improve your overall financial health can positively impact your score. Here are some practical tips to help boost your insurance score:

1. Paying Bills on Time

Pay bills consistently on time is one of the most effective ways to improve both your credit score and your insurance score. Late or missed payments are a red flag for insurers, signaling financial instability. By ensuring that all of your bills—credit cards, loans, utilities—are paid on time, you show insurers that you manage your finances responsibly, which can lead to a better score and lower premiums.

2. Reducing Credit Balances

High credit card balances relative to your credit limits can hurt your insurance score. This is referred to as your credit utilization ratio. Insurers prefer to see low balances because they suggest you’re not over-reliant on credit. Aim to keep your balances well below 30% of your credit limits, and try to pay off debts regularly. Reducing your debt not only improves your insurance score but also enhances your financial stability overall.

3. Regularly Reviewing Your Credit Report for Errors

Errors on your credit report can negatively affect your insurance score. It’s important to review your credit report regularly to ensure all the information is accurate. If you spot any mistakes, such as incorrect account information or late payments that weren’t your fault, dispute them promptly with the credit reporting agencies.

Why Maintaining a Good Credit History Is Important

Maintaining a good credit history is crucial because your insurance score is influenced by long-term financial behaviors. By managing credit responsibly over time, you improve your score and, in turn, reduce your insurance premiums. A healthy credit history reflects reliability and lowers your perceived risk to insurers​​.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

• Does checking your own credit hurt your insurance score?
  No, checking your own credit is considered a “soft inquiry” and does not affect your insurance score or credit score.
• Can you get insurance if you have a poor score?
  Yes, you can still get insurance with a high insurance score, but you may pay higher premiums because insurers view you as a higher risk.
• How often should you check your insurance score?
  It’s a good idea to check your insurance score annually or whenever you review your credit report. Regular monitoring helps ensure accuracy and can identify opportunities to improve your score.

Conclusion

Understanding your insurance score is essential because it directly impacts the cost of your insurance premiums. By knowing how your financial behaviors—such as paying bills on time and managing credit balances—affect your insurance score, you can take steps to improve it, potentially saving money on auto, home, and renters insurance. A low insurance score signals to insurers that you are less likely to file claims, which can result in lower premiums, while a high score may increase your costs.

It’s important to monitor both your credit and insurance scores regularly. Checking your credit report for errors, paying off debts, and maintaining good financial habits will help improve your scores over time. Regularly reviewing these scores can also help you spot inaccuracies or negative trends that could harm your premiums. By staying proactive with your credit management, you can ensure that your insurance score reflects your best financial habits, leading to lower insurance costs and better coverage options. Always keep an eye on your scores and make informed decisions to protect both your financial and insurance future.